Suncor argued · No. 25-170 · Oct 5 ⚖ Anderson v. Intel · ERISA benchmarks · Oct 6 ⚖ Air Force v. Prutehi Guåhan · NEPA · Oct 7 ⚖ Roberts stay · FCC v. Brown · 26A476 ⚖ DOJ voter policy vacated · D.D.C. · Oct 9 ⚖ FTC · Southern Glazer · Robinson-Patman · Oct 2 ⚖ Kalshi · Ill. sports wagering PI · N.D. Ill. ⚖ Mullin v. Nat'l TPS Alliance · GVR · Oct 5 ⚖ Suncor argued · No. 25-170 · Oct 5 ⚖ Anderson v. Intel · ERISA benchmarks · Oct 6 ⚖ Air Force v. Prutehi Guåhan · NEPA · Oct 7 ⚖ Roberts stay · FCC v. Brown · 26A476 ⚖ DOJ voter policy vacated · D.D.C. · Oct 9 ⚖ FTC · Southern Glazer · Robinson-Patman · Oct 2 ⚖ Kalshi · Ill. sports wagering PI · N.D. Ill. ⚖ Mullin v. Nat'l TPS Alliance · GVR · Oct 5 ⚖

October 5–11, 2026 · Sunday Edition · First Monday · October Sitting, Week One

Suncor Energy v. Boulder County

Two hours at the lectern — and an eight-justice bench with a 4–4 tie on the table.

8

Justices heard argument after Justice Alito recused; a deadlock would affirm Colorado and keep Boulder’s climate-damages suit alive.

Follow-up from last week’s preview: on Monday the Court convened October Term 2026 with Kannon Shanmugam urging that interstate greenhouse-gas harms cannot be redressed through Colorado nuisance law, Sarah Harris backing preemption for the United States, and Kevin Russell defending Boulder’s parallel to tobacco and opioid litigation. Justices Kavanaugh and Kagan pressed both sides on whether Clean Air Act displacement and Article III jurisdiction can be resolved without trial.

Argument transcript — Oct 5 · via CBS News

Merits preview · Clean Air Act

Federal Air Law vs. State Court Damages

Petitioners frame Boulder’s suit as a backdoor global emissions regulator; respondents say state consumer-protection and public-nuisance theories remain available when Congress has not occupied the field.

Petitioners' theory

Interstate air pollution is “inherently federal”; the Clean Air Act saving clause does not authorize monetary claims tied to worldwide GHG emissions that would second-guess EPA’s regulatory choices and foreign-affairs judgments.

VS

Respondents' theory

Colorado courts may adjudicate deceptive marketing and localized injury from fossil-fuel promotion without prescribing national emission caps — much as states once pursued opioid and tobacco defendants under parallel tort theories.

SCOTUSblog — No. 25-170

No. 25-735 · Oct 5 · Follow-on argument

“The law entitles Petitioner to judicial review, just not in district court.”

Kevin J. Barber · Assistant to the Solicitor General · Johnson v. United States Congress

Veteran Floyd Johnson asks whether 38 U.S.C. § 511(a) channels all constitutional challenges to benefit-affecting statutes into the Veterans Court — or whether district courts retain the forum this Court recognized in Johnson v. Robison (1974) for facial attacks on incarceration-related benefit reductions under § 5313.

SCOTUSblog recap — Oct 5 · Transcript

Oct 6 argument · Employee benefits

What Makes a “Meaningful Benchmark”?

In Anderson v. Intel Corporation Investment Policy Committee, the Court spent an hour on whether ERISA plaintiffs alleging fund underperformance must plead comparison to a peer fund with similar risk objectives — or may survive dismissal with holistic imprudence allegations.

Petitioners

Matthew Wessler argued the Ninth Circuit’s benchmark rule is a judicial bright line inconsistent with Dudenhoeffer’s flexible duty-of-prudence inquiry.

United States · amicus

Aimee Brown supported Intel: different investment objectives explain divergent returns; apples-to-oranges comparisons should not survive Rule 8.

Bench signals

Justices Thomas and Gorsuch pressed for a workable comparator standard; several justices appeared reluctant to bless dismissal without any benchmark at all.

via PLANADVISER · LII — No. 25-498

No. 25-579 · Oct 7

Munitions on Tarague Beach — Finality Before NEPA?

Prutehi Guåhan challenged the Air Force’s renewal application to detonate hazardous munitions under RCRA without an environmental impact statement. The government argued a permit request is never “final agency action”; justices worried both about premature suits and about agencies using RCRA to bypass NEPA entirely.

SCOTUSblog — Oct 7 · Courthouse News

October 5 orders · Summary dispositions

Conference Fallout Before the Gavel

26-48

Mullin, Sec. DHS v. National TPS Alliance — cert granted, judgment vacated, and remanded to the Ninth Circuit for reconsideration in light of Mullin v. Doe, 609 U.S. 324 (2026).

GVR

Multiple criminal judgments vacated and remanded for reconsideration after Hunter v. United States, 608 U.S. 713 (2026), and Abouammo v. United States, 608 U.S. 597 (2026).

Callais

Garcia v. Hobbs — vacated and remanded to the Ninth Circuit in light of Louisiana v. Callais, 608 U.S. 85 (2026).

Order list — Oct 5, 2026

4th Cir. · Oct 7

Mandamus to Decide Party-Rate Review

Judges King and Wynn ordered the FCC to resolve Sherrod Brown’s application for review of political-party advertising rates by noon October 9, calling the Commission’s delay an “assault on separation of powers” ahead of the November 3 election.

Opinion — 26-2230

Shadow docket · Oct 8

Chief Justice Stays the Mandate

In FCC v. Brown, No. 26A476, Chief Justice Roberts stayed the Fourth Circuit judgment pending further order and set responses due October 10 at 5 p.m. EDT — reprising September’s stay in the party-committees litigation.

Roberts order — Oct 8 · Docket 26A476

D.D.C. · Oct 9, 2026

0 pp.

Memorandum opinion vacating DOJ’s Voter List Maintenance Policy

Judge Sparkle L. Sooknanan held the Civil Rights Division exceeded statutory authority under the NVRA, HAVA, and the 1960 Civil Rights Act; acted arbitrarily; and violated the Privacy Act and Paperwork Reduction Act by demanding unredacted statewide rolls and matching them against SAVE citizenship data known to misidentify naturalized citizens.

Memorandum opinion — 1:26-cv-01352 · Courthouse News

C.D. Cal. · Oct 2, 2026

FTC’s First Robinson-Patman Settlement in a Generation

The Commission filed a consent decree with Southern Glazer’s Wine and Spirits after surviving a motion to dismiss in April — Chair Ferguson’s statement noted discovery exposed evidentiary weaknesses, but the settlement still imposes a six-year compliance program and independent monitor under 15 U.S.C. § 13 price-discrimination theories.

Alleged conduct

Favored large retailers received volume discounts unavailable to independent stores in geographic proximity — competitive injury inferred under Morton Salt.

Enforcement signal

Even a “modest harm” case can yield structural relief when Robinson-Patman returns to active dockets after decades of dormancy.

via Greenberg Traurig analysis

N.D. Ill. · October 2026

Prediction Markets vs. Illinois Sports-Wagering Law

Judge Martha M. Pacold granted partial preliminary injunctions to Kalshi, Coinbase, and the CFTC in parallel challenges to Illinois enforcement against event-contract platforms — finding federal Commodity Exchange Act preemption arguments strong enough to continue briefing while Illinois pressed its public-interest and consumer-protection defenses.

Memorandum opinion — Kalshi docket

DENIED

Oct 7, 2026 · 26A459

Jamaal Howard v. Texas

The Court denied Howard’s application for a stay of execution and certiorari petition; Justice Jackson noted she would grant the stay application. The order list carried no merits opinions — SCOTUSblog’s term counter still read zero decisions issued as of Sunday.

Order — Oct 7

9th Cir. · Filed Oct 9

Bear-Habitat Roads Under NFMA

In Alliance for the Wild Rockies v. U.S. Forest Service, No. 25-3518, the panel reversed summary judgment for environmental plaintiffs on the Hanna Flats Good Neighbor Authority Project, holding the district court failed to ask whether the Forest Service’s project — not baseline drift — caused Access Amendments road-mileage noncompliance in Idaho bear recovery zones.

Post-project mileage disputed: 338.4 mi vs. 316.4 mi cap

Opinion — Oct 9, 2026

Regulatory · Exchange Act § 36

SEC “Innovation Exemption” for Tokenized NMS Stock

Although not a court ruling, the Commission’s September 17 order granting five-year conditional relief for permissioned onchain trading of tokenized nationally listed equities — exempting certain tokenized securities venues and liquidity providers from “exchange” and “dealer” definitions — continued to reshape digital-asset practice as Kalshi and Coinbase litigators cited federal market-structure preemption in state courts this week.

WilmerHale client alert — Oct 5

The Week Ahead

Beaird v. United States

Sentencing-guidelines retroactivity and career-offender calculations — third argument week of October sitting.

Salazar v. Paramount Global

Copyright fair-use fight over archival news footage in documentary films — Sixth Circuit judgment under review.

SCOTUS order day

Likely 9:30 a.m. ET orders from the October 10 conference; first merits opinions of OT 2026 remain pending.

FCC v. Brown responses

Watch for full-Court action after October 10 opposition filings to Chief Justice Roberts’s stay of Fourth Circuit mandamus.

DOJ voter-policy appeal window

Common Cause judgment is appealable; parties may seek a stay while CR-funded agencies enter preelection posture.

Younge v. Fulton DA

First November sitting argument — prosecutorial immunity and § 1983 pleading standards from the Eleventh Circuit.

General election

FCC political-rate litigation and DOJ voter-roll disputes both orbit the same calendar — expect emergency applications through Election Day.

Continuing resolution lapse

P.L. 119-103 funding expires unless Congress replaces the stopgap during the lame-duck session.

What is Legally Brief?