Beaird v. U.S. · Stinson deference · Oct 13 ⚖ Salazar v. Paramount · VPPA · Oct 14 ⚖ FCC v. Brown · per curiam stay · 7–2 · Oct 14 ⚖ Bolton en banc · ERISA exhaustion · 11th Cir. ⚖ REPS & Co. · BOTS Act · DOJ complaint · Oct 15 ⚖ DOJ stay motion · Common Cause · Oct 16 ⚖ Herrera-Salazar cert denied · Sotomayor statement ⚖ FTC v. Amazon · Rule 26(f) set · Oct 6 order ⚖ Beaird v. U.S. · Stinson deference · Oct 13 ⚖ Salazar v. Paramount · VPPA · Oct 14 ⚖ FCC v. Brown · per curiam stay · 7–2 · Oct 14 ⚖ Bolton en banc · ERISA exhaustion · 11th Cir. ⚖ REPS & Co. · BOTS Act · DOJ complaint · Oct 15 ⚖ DOJ stay motion · Common Cause · Oct 16 ⚖ Herrera-Salazar cert denied · Sotomayor statement ⚖ FTC v. Amazon · Rule 26(f) set · Oct 6 order ⚖
No. 25-5343

October 12–18, 2026 · Sunday Edition · October Sitting, Week Two

Beaird v. United States

One hour, three advocates, and thirty years of Stinson deference on the line.

Follow-up to opening-week arguments: on Tuesday the Court turned from climate and ERISA benches to federal sentencing — asking whether courts must defer to U.S. Sentencing Commission commentary when interpreting guidelines, or independently construe 18 U.S.C. § 3553 ranges without binding glosses buried outside the guidelines themselves. Deputy Solicitor General Eric Feigin supported vacatur while court-appointed amicus Anthony Dick defended Stinson’s rule; SCOTUSblog’s same-day recap suggested the justices may refine, not abolish, commentary deference after Kisor.

via SCOTUSblog — Oct 13 · Argument transcript

Merits argument · Guideline 2K2.1

Three Lecterns, One Deference Doctrine

Petitioner Kendrick Beaird challenged a firearms-guideline enhancement tied to commentary interpreting “body armor.” The United States agreed the Fifth Circuit erred — but not that Stinson should fall.

Petitioner · Page

Assistant Federal Public Defender Kevin Joel Page urged zero deference: the Sentencing Reform Act’s notice-and-comment machinery applies only to guideline amendments, not commentary shortcuts that effectively rewrite binding ranges.

United States · Feigin

The Deputy SG argued Kisor limits still permit deference when commentary genuinely clarifies ambiguous guidelines — but not the “extreme” application below.

Court-appointed amicus · Dick

Anthony Dick defended Stinson as Congress’s express choice: commentary interpreting guidelines remains authoritative unless plainly inconsistent with the guideline text.

SCOTUSblog docket — No. 25-5343

No. 25-459 · Oct 14 argument

Salazar v. Paramount Global

Not a copyright case — a 1988 privacy statute meets the tracking pixel. Michael Salazar subscribed to Paramount’s 247Sports newsletter, watched recruiting videos while logged into Facebook, and alleged Paramount disclosed his Facebook ID and viewing history without consent under the Video Privacy Protection Act, 18 U.S.C. § 2710. The question is whether “consumer” means any subscriber to a video provider’s services or only subscribers to its audiovisual offerings.

Joshua Hammack told the Court Congress placed audiovisual limits in the definitions of “video tape service provider” and “personally identifiable information,” not in “consumer.” Paul Clement countered that expanding “consumer” to newsletter readers would sweep in readers who never press play.

Question presented — No. 25-459 · SCOTUSblog preview

Shadow docket · No. 26A476

Full Court Stays Fourth Circuit FCC Mandamus

Since last week’s Chief Justice stay: on October 14 the Court granted the government’s application in a per curiam opinion, pausing the Fourth Circuit order that had required the FCC to decide Sherrod Brown’s party-rate review within 48 hours. The majority called the mandamus an improper judicial intrusion into ongoing Commission deliberations; Justices Sotomayor and Jackson would have denied the stay.

“Our system of separation of powers does not allow the Judiciary to meddle in the workings of a coordinate branch.”

Per curiam — Oct 14, 2026 · Fourth Circuit mandamus — 26-2230

Cert denied · No. 25-6989 · Oct 13 orders

“The petition for a writ of certiorari is denied.”

Statement of Justice Sotomayor, joined by Justice Gorsuch, respecting denial

Jesus Herrera-Salazar was re-indicted under 8 U.S.C. § 1326(a) after a traffic stop while on supervised release. Sotomayor’s statement questioned whether the “found in” prosecution comported with the petitioner's prior removal order — a rare immigration crim procedure dispute surfaced on the October 13 order list alongside multiple Hunter-related GVRs.

Order list — Oct 13

October 13 conference orders

GVRs and Monsanto Echoes

26-139

Monsanto Co. v. Dennis — cert granted, judgment vacated, and remanded to California’s Fourth Appellate District for reconsideration in light of Monsanto v. Durnell, 609 U.S. 371 (2026).

25-7569

Silva Ochoa v. United States — GVR to the Eleventh Circuit under Hunter v. United States, 608 U.S. 713 (2026).

25-1367

Roofing Designs by JR v. Royal American Construction — GVR to the Fifth Circuit under Keathley v. Buddy Ayers Construction, 608 U.S. 647 (2026).

Full order list PDF

0th

En banc · Filed Oct 13, 2026

Bolton v. Inland Fresh Seafood

The full Eleventh Circuit overruled Mason v. Continental Group to the extent it required administrative exhaustion of statutory ERISA fiduciary-duty claims. Former ESOP participants alleging a $92 million inflated stock buyout may proceed in district court without first exhausting internal plan procedures — aligning Alabama, Florida, and Georgia with most sister circuits.

578 plan participants · ESOP stock purchase challenged

En banc opinion — No. 24-10084 · via PLANADVISER

Oct 15 · Consumer protection

0M

Tickets allegedly purchased by REPS & Company Inc. after circumventing issuer limits — more than $1.3 billion spent and roughly $120.8 million in resale profit, the government says, including 7,624 tickets to one Beyoncé show via 1,300 accounts. The FTC referred the case to DOJ for a BOTS Act complaint in the Southern District of California.

FTC press release — Oct 15 · DOJ announcement

Follow-up · D.D.C. · Oct 16

DOJ Seeks Stay After Voter-Policy Vacatur

A week after Judge Sooknanan vacated the Civil Rights Division’s voter-list maintenance policy, DOJ filed a stay pending appeal — arguing there is no reviewable “policy” and that Title III of the Civil Rights Act of 1960 authorizes its roll demands. Plaintiffs opposed and sought fourteen days to respond under local rules; voting groups separately warned that a new California lawsuit may conflict with the vacatur order.

Oct 9 order — CourtListener · Democracy Docket — California parallel

W.D. Wash. · 2:26-cv-03097

FTC–Amazon Ad-Auction Case Sets Discovery Calendar

New development this week: on October 6 Judge John H. Chun approved the parties’ stipulated schedule for the multistate challenge alleging Amazon converted nominally second-price ad auctions into first-price charges — 49 counts spanning 22 states. Amazon’s response deadline moved to December 7; motion-to-dismiss briefing extends into February 2027 given the word-count complexity.

Rule 26(f) conference

Initial disclosures

Amazon answer or MTD due

Plaintiffs’ MTD opposition cap

Stipulated order — Doc. 94 · FTC complaint summary

Regulatory · Commodity Exchange Act

CFTC Codifies Event-Contract Authority

While federal judges weighed Illinois preemption orders last week, the Commission continued rulemaking to clarify which retail event contracts fall under CFTC jurisdiction — a direct response to prediction-market litigation between Kalshi, Coinbase, and state gaming regulators. Comment deadlines on the retail crypto-asset framework proposal remain a forward-looking flashpoint for digital-asset lawyers even as courts split on Dodd-Frank preemption theories.

GW Regulatory Studies Digest — Oct 2026

The Week Ahead

SCOTUS order day

Likely 9:30 a.m. ET orders from the October 17 conference — watch for further FCC election litigation and criminal-law GVRs.

FTC v. Amazon Rule 26(f)

Parties must confer on discovery in the Western District of Washington ad-auction case.

Maxwell v. Dinis · Younge v. Fulton DA

November sitting opens with habeas and prosecutorial-immunity arguments.

General election

FCC political-rate stays and DOJ voter-data disputes orbit the same calendar.

Pinnacle Tunney Act comment window

Approximately 60 days after the September 18 Federal Register notice on DOJ’s RealPage/Pinnacle consent decree — public comments on the algorithmic-rent settlement.

CFTC retail crypto proposal

Comment deadline on the Commission’s framework for certain retail digital-asset transactions (per GW Regulatory Studies tracking).

Continuing resolution lapse

P.L. 119-103 funding expires unless Congress replaces the stopgap in lame-duck session.

What is Legally Brief?